top of page

AI Gives the Answer. But Does It Prevent a Mistake?

Writer: Eiger
Eiger
2 days ago
6 min read

Updated: 1 day ago

AI is increasingly good at explaining financial concepts, comparing choices, and helping people get oriented before talking with a financial professional.


Glowing AI brain and hand choose a golden path linking house, hourglass, family, growth chart and scales in a dark futuristic scene.

Maybe you asked whether to pay off your mortgage or keep investing. Maybe you asked what a Roth conversion involves or what the difference is between a healthcare power of attorney and a living will. Either way, you probably had an answer in seconds, and it was likely a reasonable one.


But an answer is not a decision.


The harder part is understanding how that answer fits with everything else already happening in your financial and personal life, and that is where most of the real work starts.


Should You Trust AI's Financial Guidance?


In the FINRA Investor Education Foundation's 2025 National Financial Capability Study, 20 percent of adults said they would be interested in getting financial insights from artificial intelligence (AI). Interestingly, a new question was added to see if the behavior had become common enough to track.


Trust in that guidance splits sharply by age. Younger Americans (25 to 45) are especially likely to turn to social media, podcasts, and AI tools for financial information. But 64 percent of that group report making regrettable financial decisions based on misleading online information. Overall, only 38 percent of Americans feel comfortable acting on guidance from AI tools, and just 37 percent trust financial information on social media. Younger households ask AI more freely, and it costs them more often.


Bar chart on trust in online financial guidance: ages 25–45 trust AI tools and social media at 44%, ages 46–64 at 26% and 24% respectively.

The same CFP Board survey found that 74 percent of Americans felt confident following their financial professional's guidance, and 62 percent said they now spend more time verifying financial information than they did five years ago. AI and a financial professional are not competing for the same job on a financial question. AI is good at explaining what a strategy is and, more generally, how it works.


Bar chart titled Measuring Trust: Financial Professionals vs. AI Insights, showing 20% prefer AI and 74% trust financial pros.

But can AI sit with you when evaluating a business sale or a vesting event that might drop money into your account overnight? A financial professional factors in your risk tolerance, your fears and aspirations, and a variety of other factors, not just what AI says in a chat.


That combination can lead to more confidence.


What Can't AI Do?


AI can be a starting point. It can explain how a Roth conversion works, walk through the mechanics of a required minimum distribution, and lay out the trade-offs between using a credit card and paying cash for a purchase. AI can also ask a clarifying follow-up question before answering.


What AI can’t do is sit with someone during periods of market volatility. Vanguard's long-running research on a financial professional's value, known as Advisor's Alpha, has repeatedly pointed to exactly this kind of behavioral coaching—keeping a client focused on their strategy—as one of the largest single contributors to that value. In fact, Vanguard estimates that behavioral coaching can contribute up to 2 percentage points in additional net annual returns.


Beige infographic reading Up to +2 percentage points, saying behavioral coaching from a financial professional boosts net annual return.

DALBAR's research shows why that discipline can be worth paying for. In its 2026 Quantitative Analysis of Investor Behavior (QAIB) report, DALBAR found that the average equity fund investor earned 17.16 percent in 2025, compared with the S&P 500's 17.88 percent, a gap of just 72 basis points and one of the narrowest recorded since 1985. The year before told a much different story: In 2024, the average equity investor earned 16.54 percent while the S&P 500 returned 25.02 percent, a staggering gap of 848 basis points. The contrast illustrates how dramatically the difference between investor returns and market performance can vary from year to year. While several factors contribute to that difference, investors' decisions about when to buy, sell, or remain invested can have a meaningful impact on their long-term results—and that is when a financial professional's judgment can be particularly valuable.


AI can describe past market events and explain the difference between remaining invested and market timing. Unless you tell AI, it has no way of knowing that you are three years from retirement, already unsettled by a health scare in the family, and one more bad headline away from calling to sell everything. A financial professional who has sat through that before can act as what Vanguard calls an “emotional circuit breaker.”


The same dynamic shows up after a business sale or a large vesting event lands in one account at once. Some people freeze and let the cash sit for a year, afraid of getting the next step wrong. Others move fast, putting the windfall into a new investment within weeks. AI can model either path, but unless you tell AI, it has no way of knowing which instinct you might lean towards.


Is It OK to Bring an AI Answer Into Your Next Financial Professional Conversation?


Yes! Bring it with you. If you have asked AI a financial question, there is no reason to start the conversation over from scratch; share the question you asked and the answer you received, and then let the meeting focus on resolving the issue.


Instead of asking what a Roth conversion is, you may be ready to ask about the pros and cons of a partial conversion. Instead of asking whether you should pay off the mortgage, the sharper version may be a discussion of the outlook for interest rates.


Reframed that way, AI can advance the financial conversation instead of just prefacing it. It gets you to the second question, which might leave more time to review other ideas.


What Should the Final Decision Account For?


The full list depends on the decision, but it usually draws from some combination of your goals, time horizon, and risk tolerance, as well as your estate ideas, charitable focus, and whatever else is already underway. A combination of factors can help when facing the decision: “What do I do next?”


How We Can Help


Bring us the questions you asked and the answers you got back. We will review the ideas and see what has already been built into your roadmap. The research you already did is not wasted; it may simply be the first draft of a broader conversation.


Frequently Asked Questions


Is it safe to ask AI a financial question?

AI can be a starting point for general research and understanding how a strategy works. Be careful if you’re asked to enter sensitive personal or account details.


Should I follow specific insights from AI?

Before acting on them, ask yourself, “How much does AI know about my whole financial picture?” If AI has a limited understanding of the situation, it might have limited insights.


What should I bring to my financial professional if I already researched something with AI?

Bring the question you asked and the answer you received, along with whatever part still feels unresolved. That can help frame a conversation.


Can AI replace a financial professional?

AI is developing rapidly, but remember, AI only knows what you have told it. While you may think you’ve told AI everything it needs to know, it may base its answers on partial information. A trained financial professional has learned to ask questions that can help create a better understanding of what’s important to you. And it can be hard to place a value on that insight.


Sources & Disclosures

The information contained on this site is intended for general informational purposes only, may not reflect current developments; does not constitute investment, tax, or legal advice; and should not be relied upon for such purposes. Estate planning rules vary significantly by state and individual circumstances. There is no guarantee that any forecasts made will come to pass. We make no representation about the accuracy of the information or its appropriateness for any given situation. This information is not an offering. Past performance does not guarantee future results.


 
 
bottom of page